On Moonlight Bay

Warner Bros, 1951
Starring Doris Day, Gordon MacRae, Billy Gray, and Leon Ames
Directed by Roy Del Ruth
Music and Lyrics by various composers

This is the second of three nostalgic musicals Day made during the period where she was America's girl-next-door and the biggest musical star at Warner Bros. It's loosely based after the Penrod novels by Booth Tarkington, which was a series of stories about a mischievous little boy in the early 20th century. While the movie does focus mostly on the romantic exploits of his sister, the boy does have his own important plots. Does this excursion into times past float along like the lyrics in the title song, or should it be sent out the door with a slingshot? Let's head to a small Indiana town in 1916 and find out...

The Story: The Winfield family has just moved across town to a far larger home in an upwardly-mobile neighborhood. Mr Winfield (Ames) is the only one who thinks it's a good idea. His son Wesley (Gray) misses his friends, and his tomboy daughter Marjorie (Day) would rather be playing baseball than courting some dull young man. That changes when she meets handsome college boy William Sherman (MacRae) after almost shooting him when she was trying to keep Westley from playing with a gun. They go on a date and fall in love, but William has a lot of high-minded ideas about capitalism and the role of money and marriage in society. Marjorie claims that she agrees with them, but her banker father isn't as thrilled. He'd rather see Marjorie married to the steady but bland Hubert (Jack Smith). He's even less happy when Bill joins the army to head for France.

Eleven-year-old Westley has his own problems, most of them stemming from his attempts to avoid schoolwork and his wild imagination. He accidentally brings a love note from Marjorie to Bill to school for a class assignment; his attempts to get back at her and send Hubert packing make his sister happy instead of angry. He gets between Marjorie and Bill when the lie he tells his teacher (Ellen Corby) about his father being a drinker gets back to Bill, and he thinks Marjorie's father has hurt her. Wesley is ultimately the one who finally changes his father's mind about his sister and her beau when he uses a slingshot that used to belong to his father...and reminds Mr. Wakefield that he was a boy once, too.

The Song and Dance: Gray's antics and Day's feisty personality really give this one a lift. Marjorie may give up baseball for romance, but she's going to have it her way, no matter what her father says. Wesley's daydreaming is mostly what causes the problems, especially during one sequence in school where he imagines he's flying that reminds me a lot of A Christmas Story. Leon Ames and Rosemary DeCamp as his wife are fine as the Winfield parents; Mary Wickes is hilarious as the sarcastic maid Stella, whom everyone keeps running into when her hands are full.

Favorite Number: Day and MacRae have a charming version of "Cuddle Up a Little Closer" early in the film that's disrupted by Wesley's attempts to sing along. Day's tearful "Till We Meet Again" and "Tell Me" after she and Bill have been separated the first time and "Christmas Story" after the incident with Wesley and the lie about his father are her best solo numbers.

What I Don't Like: Wesley is seriously lucky he never got more than a scolding for any of the trouble he caused, including spreading a rather nasty rumor about his father and stealing his sister's letter. Mr. Winfield was a bit of a jerk throughout much of the movie; not only would some people today probably agree with Bill's views on marriage, but I suspect many fathers in the 21st century would be proud to have a soldier for a son. And yeah, a lot of this isn't anything you haven't seen before in dozens of coming-of-age stories going as far back as the Winfields' time.

The Big Finale: Charming and cute if you like the cast, Day, or nostalgic tales of growing up in the 20th century. This ended up being a huge hit for Warners, enough to warrant a sequel in 1953.

Home Media: As one of Day's most popular films, this is easily found online, both on streaming and on DVD.

DVD
TCM: On Moonlight Bay/By the Light of the Silvery Moon
Amazon Prime