Starring Lucas Grabeel, Adrian Slade, Drew Seely, and Amy Paffrath
Directed by Chris Nolan
Music by Frankie Blue; Lyrics by Frankie Blue and Chris Nolan
Let's celebrate the spookiest night of the year with a teen horror musical that's so bad, it's scary. Apparently, this began as a three-part iTunes webseries of the same title in 2009. That went over so well, it was expanded into full-on musical form in 2010 and was released briefly into theaters in 2012. It was dumped onto streaming and disc shortly afterwards. I'll be honest, I never even heard of this until I started digging around for horror musicals to review for Halloween this year. Is it a diamond in the rough, or should this blood sucker be defanged? Let's begin as Dylan Knight (Grabeel) explains how he was turned into a vampire to "para-psychologist" Dr. Lori Light (Lori Lively) and find out...
The Story: Dylan's not sure how to deal with any of this, and he doesn't like what it's doing to his relationship with his sweet girlfriend Sarah Lane (Slade). He's terrified that he might lose control and hurt her. She's not sure what to think, especially since he won't tell her what's going on. He's taken under the wing of vampire rock star Trey Sylvania (Seely), who has his own harem of groupies who are addicted to him. Dylan doesn't really want to have anything to do with him, his women, or being a vampire, but he keeps insisting on showing him a good time. It's even worse when Trey brings Sarah and Dylan to his own demonic club. He manages to place Sarah under his control and turn her into a vampire too.
Dylan is so horrified with how his beloved Sarah is changing into someone he doesn't know, he takes Dr. Light's advice and brings her to Dr. Dan Helsing (Chris Coppola). Helsing doesn't know about vampires, but he does know about venom and being bitten by things you don't want sinking their fangs into you. He agrees to make a potion that will change them back into ordinary humans, if he can get a drop of their blood. Trey, however, still has her in his power. He brings both of them to his home to turn her completely to his side. His head groupie Luna Dark (Paffrath) would rather turn her into a frog, but she still agrees to make her over. The groupies have less luck seducing Dylan, who just wants Sarah and his life back. He'll have to embrace his inner vampire and confront Trey on his terms if he's ever going to bring back his girlfriend.
The Song and Dance: I do give them credit for going a little scarier than Disney ever attempted in their ZOMBIES series. This isn't a bunch of monsters dancing around and having star-crossed romances. There's real blood and gore here, and we actually see the kids being turned into vampires.
The Numbers: We open with Trey and his band telling Dylan "Welcome to the Underworld" in his nightmare. Sarah sings about how she feels like her boyfriend has become a "Forbidden Planet" as people dance around her at the fair grounds after a date goes badly. Dylan just wants Trey to get "Outta My Head." He and Luna sing about how "Love's In Vein" at the club. All Dylan needs is just a "Little Peck" to get Sarah out of Trey's arms. Sarah explains how she needs "Just a Drop" of red to a horrified Dylan as they dance in a local steak house, and the diners dance along. "Be the Bite," says Trey. Sarah encourages Dylan to just give Dr. Helsing and his crazy potions a "Try."
"Poison Is My Passion," Helsing explains to the kids when they ask him to make them human again. Those vampires are "Out for Blood," and all they need is a drop for that potion. They need to do it quick, because Trey can still "Feel U" and still has Sarah in his power. "I'd Kill for U," Trey tells Luna, even though they can't die. He encourages Luna and the groupies to make Sarah into a "Shiny New Vampire." Dylan is less thrilled to "Dance With Darkness" when Desiree Damned (Emily Morris) makes a play for him. Trey sings his "Forbidden Ballad" with Sarah as he pulls her further and further into his thrall. Helsing tells Dylan he has to "Dig Down Deep" to really feel Sarah. The movie ends as Sarah and Dylan live "Happily Afterlife" and embrace their vampirism in the finale under the closing credits.
What I Don't Like: This is almost more of a cheap B movie than Up In the Air. At least that made sense. There's plot holes galore here, especially if, like me, you haven't seen the web series this is based on. They barely explain how Dylan became a vampire in the first place. The dancing is terrible, with people barely moving in formation, and the filming is worse. Nolan tends to focus on the singer and not the group, which means we frequently don't get to see what half the dancers are doing. Grabeel's whiny Dylan loses any charm points he might have picked up in the High School Musical films and is too sweet to be a brooding vampire. Luna hints about Trey being the "Prince of Darkness," but they don't really go further into it. Trey's a flat-out jerk, to the point where you wonder how all those groupies can stand to be around him, and Slade is blank and has little to do even when she's not in a vampire's thrall. The music is silly, bland, and not at all memorable.
The Big Finale: Only for the most ardent 13-15-year-old horror or High School Musical enthusiasts. Anyone else can pass this blood sucker by without another thought. There are better ways to spend your Halloween.
Home Media: Can be found all over streaming. Tubi currently has it for free with commercials. The DVD isn't that cheap at press time.